Controversial Mansion House Live Crib launches, despite animal welfare concerns
The Live Animal Crib has launched at Mansion House on Dawson Street despite criticisms from animal welfare groups
The annual installation - which usually features a live sheep, donkey and goat - was launched by Lord Mayor Councillor Ray McAdam and the president of the Irish Farmers Association Francie Gorman today. Described as a “cherished Christmas tradition in the heart of the city,” the temporary fixture has previously been condemned by the National Animal Rights Association (NARA) as going against the welfare of the animals involved.
Speaking on Newstalk Breakfast, NARA spokesperson Laura Broxson explained the animals are transported back and forth to farms everyday and that it’s “not a natural environment" for them. “They might have food, water and bedding but they’re not going to be used to the noise, the lights, people banging on the perspex.”
She suggested animatronic displays instead and said there are many other ways to recreate the nativity without involving real animals. However, IFA president Gorman said Ireland has “highest animal welfare standards in the world” and cited the crib as one of the most enjoyable things he does each year.
This ongoing controversy saw former Lord Mayor Caroline Conroy choose not to have a Live Animal Crib in 2022 , a move that was described in some reports as "grinch-like." However, a live crib still went ahead without the Lord Mayor's involvement that year as the Irish Farmers’ Association hosted it at the Summer House in St Stephen’s Green.
Speaking at the launch this morning, Lord Mayor McAdam said the Mansion House has been at the heart of Christmas celebration for generations. “The Live Animal Crib is a tradition shaped and sustained by Dubliners themselves, by families who return year after year, by children whose excitement fills the forecourt, and by the community spirit that defines our city,” he said.
“"What makes this crib truly special is not just the animals or the setting, but the way it brings Dubliners together. It reminds us of the values that run deep in this city: community, kindness, neighbourliness, and that unmistakable Dublin welcome.
“For so many Dublin families, the crib is part of their Christmas story. Seeing the joy on children’s faces as they meet the animals up close is a moment that never loses its magic, it’s a reminder of everything good about this time of year and everything great about Dubliners.
“I’d encourage everyone to drop by, soak up the festive atmosphere, and share in a tradition that belongs to all of us, a tradition rooted in the heart, heritage, and generosity of Dublin and its people.”
Mr Gorman added that “it’s a tradition that speaks to the values we hold dear, family, community and care for animals.” “For farm families, looking after livestock is a year-round commitment, and this crib is a small reminder of that work,” he said.
“We’re proud to continue this partnership with the Lord Mayor and Dublin City Council , and I’d encourage everyone visiting the city to call in, experience the crib and take a moment to reflect on what makes Christmas so special."
This content is funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme