Michael Maguire wins permission in dentist surveillance dispute

This report is a localnews.ie summary based on public court reporting and records; sources are listed below.

Michael Maguire was granted permission to serve short notice of proceedings against James Hiney at the High Court on 26 June 2018, in a dispute over alleged surveillance and patient data. The proceedings concern separate dental practices operated from a building the dentists co-own at Market Point, Mullingar, Co Westmeath.

Mr Maguire alleges that a camera, wiring and a microphone were installed above a reception area without his consent, capturing staff activity, personal files and patient data. His counsel said Mr Hiney’s solicitor had stated in correspondence that the camera was installed on Garda advice over an alleged theft of money from the premises. Counsel said Mr Maguire did not accept this explanation, citing a specialist report that showed an image of his staff working at their part of the reception desk.

Mr Maguire also seeks orders concerning alleged patient solicitation, the return of data and proposed construction works. Ms Justice Costello granted the permission on an ex parte basis. The matter was due to return before the court later that week.