Judgment: 2017-05-04 · Court archive

Dublin Children’s Court defers teenager’s 18-month detention sentence for six months

The court found the child had reached the custody threshold after repeated dangerous driving offences, but deferred detention under supervision and set a review hearing.

The Children Court- Dublin Metropolitan District Court [as printed with apparent OCR error in source heading] · [2017] IEDC 7

Who, what, where, when and why

Who
  • Judge John O’Connor
  • parish priest
What

The court found the child had reached the custody threshold after repeated dangerous driving offences, but deferred detention under supervision and set a review hearing.

Where

Places mentioned in the report

  • Dublin
  • M50
  • Youthreach
When

Judgment:

Why

Reasons reported in the judgment

The court rejected alternatives including community sanctions, suspended sentences and adjourned supervision, saying the child needed certainty of sentence alongside support and a defined court review. It ordered compliance with conditions set by the Probation Service and directed that the child receive an explanation of the deferred order and possible consequences of failing to comply. The total driving disqualification was six years.

The Dublin Children’s Court imposed an 18-month detention sentence on a teenager convicted of a series of road traffic offences, then deferred the sentence for six months under supervision by the Probation Service.

Judge John O’Connor said the child had reached the threshold for custody. The court set a resumed hearing for six months from the date of the hearing, with an updated probation report to be provided. The judgment does not state the exact hearing date.

The offences included dangerous driving, driving without a licence or insurance, and taking vehicles without the owners’ consent. The incidents described in the judgment occurred between January and November 2016. In one, the teenager drove a scrambler motorbike into two cars; no one was injured, but one car was written off. In another, he drove a stolen car at speed, ran red lights and crossed the M50, forcing other drivers to take evasive action. The car was also written off.

A later incident involved a stolen car colliding with a Volkswagen Golf driven by a parish priest. The priest suffered broken ankles and a hairline fracture to his knee, spent six weeks in hospital and said he had not fully recovered. In an impact statement, he described missing work and family activities and continuing to face hospital appointments and expenses. The judgment also recounts the loss suffered by another car owner whose vehicle was written off while her husband was seriously ill in hospital; he later died.

The court identified persistent offending while on bail, disregard for human life, leaving an accident scene and failures to appear in court as aggravating factors. It cited the child’s age, lack of previous convictions, personal circumstances, guilty pleas and remorse in mitigation. The judge said the child had engaged well with bail support and probation services.

The court rejected alternatives including community sanctions, suspended sentences and adjourned supervision, saying the child needed certainty of sentence alongside support and a defined court review. It ordered compliance with conditions set by the Probation Service and directed that the child receive an explanation of the deferred order and possible consequences of failing to comply. The total driving disqualification was six years.

The judgment describes the child’s family as homeless and living in bed-and-breakfast accommodation in Dublin. It also records that the child had been attending Youthreach five days a week since early 2017.

Read the original court judgment

Something looks wrong?

Highlight the relevant passage or flag this article for review. Review requests do not immediately change the report.

Email a correction request

Request a review