'Citizen journalist' Philip Dwyer will have conviction dismissed, judge indicates

“Citizen journalist” Philip Dwyer, who was convicted of failing to comply with a garda’s direction to move on while live-streaming during a riot, will have his case dismissed on appeal, a judge has indicated.
Lawyers for Dwyer argued before the District Court Appeals Court that the incident happened “far too quickly”, with just 17 seconds elapsing in the time between the direction and the arrest.
The court also heard that in a statement, the senior garda who issued the instruction said that he had recognised Dwyer as a “right wing agitator online”. In his own evidence, Dwyer told the court that it was demeaning to be described in this way by the inspector and that he thought this was “biased and prejudiced”.
In February last year Dwyer (57) with an address in Tallaght, Dublin 24, was convicted in the District Court of failing to comply with a direction given by a garda member under section 8 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 1994 close to the former Crown Paints factory in Coolock, Dublin on July 15, 2024.
Dwyer, who had denied the charge, was given a two-month suspended sentence along with a 500 euro fine. He later lodged an appeal against his conviction.
The site on the Northside of Dublin had been the scene of violence, arson attacks, criminal damage and long-term protest over plans to house international protection applicants in the former warehouse.
Mr Dwyer’s case made legal history as the first time garda body-camera footage was used in a court case.
On Wednesday, Detective Inspector Alan McDevitt told the District Court Appeals Court that he was in charge of a public order unit responding to the aftermath of a serious public disorder incident at an anti-immigration protest.
He said that he had arrived at the scene at Malahide Road, Artane about an hour before encountering Dwyer. He said that there were around 200 people gathered in the area of the Crown Paints factory in Coolock.
He said that gardai were attempting to clear the scene and some of the crowd fled into an industrial estate, where he encountered a group of people, including Dwyer, in a walkway.
He said that Dwyer was standing in front of him with a phone videoing the scene and holding a microphone.
Det Insp McDevitt said that he made a requirement under section 8 of the public order act for Dwyer to leave the area but the appellant did not leave and proceeded to ask him questions.
He said that Dwyer told him he was live streaming to thousands of people at the time.
Defence counsel, Luke O’Higgins BL, said there was no suggestion that his client was involved in any of the violent incidents prior to the events.
Det Insp McDevitt said he believes Dwyer’s role at these events was to take video content to “stir up fear” and apprehension among the public. He said that he believes Dwyer stokes anger among the crowd.
Mr O’Higgins said that the inspector wrote in his statement that he recognised Dwyer as a “right wing agitator online”.
Counsel said that 17 seconds had elapsed in the time between the detective inspector giving a direction to his client to leave the scene and the arrest.
He said that there were mixed signals – in that the inspector was telling his client to leave the scene but also telling him to give him his name.
Det Insp McDevitt replied that by asking him questions and standing there, Dwyer was not leaving the scene. The witness said he did not believe that being a citizen or mainstream journalist was a reason for not complying with a direction.
Mr O’Higgins said that the time interval between making the direction and making the arrest was too quick. He said that only 17 seconds had elapsed and that it was “blatant” from the bodycam footage shown in court that both parties were moving at the time.
He said that the incident happened “far too quickly” and that his client was not given the opportunity to comply with the order.
Counsel for the State, Rory Staines, said legislation clearly states that once a direction is given, the person must leave immediately.
He said it was clear from the bodycam footage that Dwyer decided to have a confrontation with the inspector and that he was not going to leave.
In his own evidence, Dwyer told the court that he received word something was happening in Coolock and went there in his role as a “citizen journalist” to record events in the public interest.
He said that the detective inspector walked toward him and there were no circumstances in which he wanted to interview him.
Dwyer said that he asked the detective inspector what was happening and felt threatened with arrest straight away.
He said that he has “no clue” what a “far right agitator” means and that he was trying to plead his case that he was a reporter.
Dwyer said that he “probably went into defence mode” but that he was complying and they were both moving.
He said it was demeaning to be described as a far right agitator by the inspector and that he thought this was “biased and prejudiced”.
The appellant said he was aware that the inspector knew who he was and had singled him out.
Dwyer said he was fully prepared to leave the area and there were no circumstances where he was not going to do so. He said that he would have left if he hadn’t been arrested.
In his submissions, Mr Staines told the court the evidence was clear that Mr Dwyer didn’t comply, didn’t leave immediately and that is why he was arrested.
However, Mr O’Higgins said that his client was walking “stride by stride” with the inspector and that they were asking each other questions and moving.
He said that in the 17 seconds between direction and arrest, the bodycam evidence showed that Dwyer was complying.
Judge Ronan Munro said that he was concerned about the “speedy” and “rapid” arrest.
He said it was clear to him that Dwyer took umbrage at being threatened with arrest by the inspector.
The judge said that in saying he wanted to “plead his case” and that he was not answering questions, Dwyer showed that there was non-compliance and that the offence was made out.
Judge Munro said that under the public order act, the gardai have a “far reaching power” and are entitled to make these swift arrests.
However, he said that it would be hard to convict Dwyer of the offence and that he could see how the appellant may not have realised the law was that extensive.
He said that he was inclined to leave Dwyer without a conviction by dismissing him under section 1(1) Probation of Offenders Act, 1907 on the condition that he pay a sum of 200 euro to the garda benevolent fund within four weeks.
Judge Munro adjourned the case until February 24 to confirm that the payment has been made.