Man has conviction for breaching protection order overturned

A man has had his conviction for breaching a protection order by allegedly grabbing his ex partner’s arm during an argument over a child’s car seat overturned on appeal.
The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was involved in an argument with his ex-partner about the security of a car seat when the complainant alleged that he grabbed her arm.
The man pleaded not guilty in the District Court to breaching a protection order contrary to section 33 (1) of the Domestic Violence Act 2018 by putting her in fear by grabbing her arm during an argument.
He was convicted and given a six-month sentence, which was fully suspended, and later lodged an appeal against that conviction.
Garda Charles Breslin told the District Court Appeals Court on Thursday that on October 16, 2024 he attended a 999 call at a residence in Dublin.
He said the complainant told him she and her ex-partner got into a verbal argument in relation to a child’s car seat.
Gda Breslin said that she told him that the man grabbed her arm and pushed her. He said that he did not see any marks on the woman’s arms but that she was visibly upset and shaken. He said that he could see that she had been crying before he arrived.
The complainant gave evidence that the man was “getting ratty” with her during the argument. She said that he put his hand on her right arm and removed her with force.
She said that he used enough force to move her back. She said that he had never “put his hands on her” in the past and that she was in shock. She said that the action left her upset and scared.
Defence counsel for the man, Oisín Clarke BL, argued that the only point where the appellant’s hand went anywhere near the complainant’s was when he was demonstrating that the seat belt had tension.
The defence showed footage of the argument, taken by the appellant, showing the man and woman arguing while she attempted to secure the car seat in the car.
The complainant said that the action of him touching her arm could not be seen in the footage because the camera was angled away during that period.
The man could be heard in the footage saying: “you had put your hand on my hand and I put it away”.
She can be heard saying “don’t ever put your hands on me”.
Mr Clarke said that the footage showed that the woman was annoyed but not in fear.
Counsel for the prosecution said that a person’s reaction is not always immediate and that the woman said she overrides her emotions when it comes to her children.
Judge Deirdre Browne said that the complainant was an “impressive witness” and it was abundantly clear that her concerns at the time were entirely justified as the car seat was not secure.
Judge Browne said she accepted that while the woman was taking steps to secure the seat, the pair came into very close physical proximity and contact occurred at a very early stage in the encounter.
She said she didn’t doubt that the complainant experienced what she thought was a push and that she didn’t think the woman was concocting a story.
Judge Browne said that her concern was for the intention of the action and that the “contact was probably likely to be inadvertent on his part”.
She said that no push was acted with intentionality or recklessness and that this action does not meet the threshold to convict for a breach of the order which was obtained.
Judge Browne decided to allow the appeal against conviction on those grounds.