'Rude' shoplifter gets concurrent prison sentence for stealing €5 can

A shoplifter who repeatedly interrupted proceedings at Dún Laoghaire District Court has been given a one-month prison sentence after admitting to stealing a €5 can of alcohol.
Thomas Carlyle (49), who is currently serving a sentence in Mountjoy Prison, pleaded guilty to stealing a “Buzzball” alcoholic drink worth €5.58 from Spar, Kilmacud Road Lower, Stillorgan, on 27 September 2024, contrary to Section 4 of the Criminal Justice Act 2001.
During the hearing, Carlyle interrupted several times. Judge Anne Watkin said she would “ignore his utter rudeness and the fact that he’s in contempt of court”, before adding that she would not deal with the case until the defendant calmed down. She then left the courtroom and returned later to hear Carlyle’s plea in mitigation.
Defence counsel, Michael O’Brien BL, said that his client had struggled with addiction issues for many years but had been “off everything” since entering custody. He said Carlyle had suffered personal difficulties, including the recent death of his mother.
Mr O’Brien pointed out that his client had no convictions between 1998 and 2021, but had “gone off the rails” after falling back into addiction. He said Carlyle was now doing better in custody and was engaging positively.
The court heard that Carlyle has 19 previous convictions, including those for theft, burglary, larceny, possession of drugs, criminal damage, road-traffic offences, and public-order matters.
He is currently serving a 12-month prison sentence for burglary, which began in July of this year.
Judge Watkin noted the low value of the stolen item but said the accused was already serving a prison term for similar offences. Judge Watkin convicted him and imposed a one-month prison sentence, to run concurrently with his existing sentence.