Musician (69) fined for dangerous driving after ‘panic’ claim rejected

A musician who sped away from gardaí in Tallaght after they said he shouted abuse from his car has been fined €750 for dangerous driving.
Christopher Farrell (69), of Suncroft Drive, Tallaght, pleaded not guilty to two counts of dangerous driving on 9 July, 2023. Judge Patricia McNamara dismissed one charge, relating to an incident on Fortunestown Way, but convicted him of a second count when the matter continued outside his home.
Tallaght District Court heard that Farrell drove up behind an unmarked patrol car on Fortunestown Way at speed, flashing his headlights repeatedly. Garda David Sheehan, of Rathfarnham Garda Station, said Farrell shouted “f***ing arseholes” before suddenly accelerating away.
He said Garda John Dalton later approached the driver’s side window of the vehicle when Farrell drove off so fast that dust rose from the central median. The court was told Farrell then turned into the Suncroft estate, sounding his horn before pulling into his driveway.
Garda Sheehan said Farrell got out “extremely aggressive,” threw his keys on the bonnet, and handed his phone to a woman. Other units were called to assist in arresting him. Farrell was cautioned and replied: “The gardaí are telling lies.”
CCTV footage from the junction was downloaded and shown in court.
Defence solicitor Deirdre McDonagh said Farrell, a pensioner and working musician, had been returning home from a gig in Rush. She said he flashed his lights because he believed the car in front had no rear lights and claimed he thought he was being attacked, citing a spate of local shootings and the criminal involvement of a person known to him.
Farrell told the court: “I got the biggest fright of my life.”
Judge McNamara recalled Garda Sheehan to confirm that the patrol car had been inspected before the shift and was in perfect working order.
Prosecuting counsel, Dr Sean Smyth BL, argued that once gardaí had identified themselves and switched on the patrol car’s blue lights, it was not credible for Farrell to continue claiming panic, particularly outside his own home.
Judge Patricia McNamara said she was not satisfied the Fortunestown Way allegation had been proven and dismissed that charge.
However, she found Farrell guilty of the Jobstown incident, saying his speeding had placed the gardaí at risk. She said that once the blue lights were activated and gardaí identified themselves, it should have been clear who they were, and even if Farrell was in fear or panic; “that does not mean your driving was not dangerous”.
She noted two minor previous road traffic matters – a Probation Act disposal in 2008 and a bus lane offence in 2015 – but did not impose a disqualification.
Farrell, who the court heard has been married for more than 50 years and is the guardian of his granddaughter, was fined €750 with five months to pay. Recognisance was fixed in the event of an appeal.