The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a direct appeal by businessman Denis O'Brien against a High Court decision on his data protection complaint about a dossier prepared by Red Flag Consulting Limited. Woulfe J., Hogan J. and Donnelly J. granted leave on 10 July 2026.
The appeal could decide how far personal data in the dossier can be withheld. Mr O'Brien has been in long-running litigation with Red Flag over a dossier prepared for an unidentified client. In 2017 the Court of Appeal refused his request for discovery.
On 2 July 2020, he made a complaint to the Data Protection Commission. The Commission refused it. It held that section 60 of the Data Protection Act 2018 restricted his right of access because of the legal proceedings. It also held that some material was protected by legal professional privilege, and that Red Flag could refuse to provide data that might reveal its client's identity.
Mr O'Brien appealed to the High Court. On 20 February 2026 Lankford J. refused the appeal. She held that section 60 was compatible with EU law and that the Commission was entitled to take the confidentiality claim into account.
Mr O'Brien said the appeal concerns provisions of the GDPR that are not clear, including Article 23(2), on which there is no reported case law. He proposed questions for the Court of Justice of the EU. The Commission opposed and said the grounds were not properly particularised.
The Supreme Court said the appeal raises potentially novel issues of great importance on litigation privilege and confidentiality. It said these questions have not yet been considered by the Supreme Court or the Court of Justice.
Mr O'Brien must give greater clarity on his grounds of appeal and the relief he seeks during case management.
Leave is granted.