James Ó Murthuile has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over planning permission for a house in County Tipperary. Hogan J., Hyland J. and O'Moore J. gave the determination on 7 July 2026.
The permission was granted to Martin Flynn for renovations and alterations to an existing house, a septic tank, a percolation area and parking. Mr Ó Murthuile objected, and An Bord Pleanála decided on 5 December 2023 to grant it. That body has since been replaced by An Coimisiún Pleanála.
Mr Ó Murthuile brought a judicial review in the High Court. He said the house was derelict and its residential use had been abandoned. On 19 September 2025, Farrell J. found the decision valid. The judge also refused him a certificate allowing an appeal to the Court of Appeal.
He then asked the Supreme Court for a direct appeal. He said it raised questions on resumed residential use of a derelict house and when use of a pre-1963 structure is abandoned. The commission opposed.
The Supreme Court said it was a clear example of a case where the applicant wanted to reargue the facts. It agreed with the High Court judge that it was "in essence a merits-based appeal on the facts". It said that having no further review does not alone mean the interests of justice require leave.