Susan Moss, Anne Hoek, Anne Lacey, Francis Prendergast, Ned Barron and Paul Davis have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over a solar development in County Kilkenny. O'Malley J., Woulfe J. and O'Moore J. gave the determination on 3 July 2026. The Court said no matter of general public importance arose.
Lightsource Renewable Energy Ireland Limited applied to Kilkenny County Council on 27 February 2023 for permission for the development. The council decided to grant permission. The applicants appealed, and An Coimisiún Pleanála granted a ten-year permission.
The commission decided that no environmental impact assessment was needed for certain internal access tracks. The applicants said a mandatory assessment was required, because private roads of more than 2,000 metres need one and the development has about 5.3km of roads.
Humphreys J. dismissed their judicial review in the High Court on 10 February 2026. He said they had not shown that the tracks were "roads" under the EU directive. He said the permission was for stone or crushed stone finish.
The applicants asked for a direct appeal to the Supreme Court. The commission said the High Court had followed an earlier case, Cummins, where the same point was rejected.
The Supreme Court said the High Court applied well-established principles and that the applicants had not disputed that Cummins was correct. It said they had shown no error, so an appeal was not needed in the interests of justice.