localnews.ie

Florin Mazarache refused Supreme Court appeal over Covid-19 fixed payment notice

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

His application was one of two near-identical cases by a father and son, and the Court said it had become moot by November 2025.

Florin Mazarache has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over a fixed payment notice, in a determination delivered on 3 July 2026. The Court said he had suffered no injustice.

Mr Mazarache was served with a fixed payment notice under the Health Act 1947, as amended. The alleged offences arose around the time of Covid-19. He said the notice was invalid and the respondents should not be able to prosecute him.

The High Court (Jackson J.) found the notice was invalid but refused relief. It said the problem was for the District Court to deal with at trial. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal.

Mr Mazarache told the Supreme Court the case involved "a new enforcement mechanism in criminal law". The Garda Commissioner, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Minister for Health opposed. They said the scheme was a pandemic measure that has lapsed.

The respondents also said a letter of 19 November 2025 told him a direction had been issued not to prosecute.

The Supreme Court said:

"There is no question of any injustice being visited on Florin Mazarache, as there will now be no prosecution of him for any offence in respect of which the FPN was issued."

It said the relevant provisions lapsed in March 2022. It had not been told of other prosecutions its decision could affect.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal