localnews.ie

Theophilus Clegg refused Supreme Court appeal over West Wood Gym fall claim

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court had found he did not prove what caused his fall in a locker room at the Sandymount gym owned by Templeville Developments.

Theophilus Clegg has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his personal injuries claim against Templeville Developments Limited. O'Malley, Collins and Hyland JJ. gave the determination on 1 July 2026.

Mr Clegg claimed that he slipped and fell on a wet surface in the men's locker room at West Wood Gym, St John's Road, Sandymount, Dublin, on 18 February 2015. The Circuit Court dismissed his claim, and he appealed to the High Court.

In a judgment on 23 April 2024, the High Court (Egan J.) dismissed his appeal. It accepted that he genuinely believed water caused his fall but found the evidence did not support that conclusion. It said he had not proved the cause on the balance of probabilities.

Mr Clegg asked the Supreme Court for leave to appeal directly, arguing that the trial judge erred in assessing the evidence and was biased against him. Templeville Developments opposed the application.

The Supreme Court said the case turned on a finding of fact about the cause of the fall. It said an appeal aimed at displacing such a finding does not meet the constitutional criteria. It added that he had already had two hearings, in the Circuit Court and the High Court, and had put forward no evidence of bias or exceptional circumstances.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal