The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by the Minister for Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth in a redress case taken by Marie Thornton. O'Malley, Collins and Hyland JJ. granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 30 June 2026. Ms Thornton did not oppose the application.
Ms Thornton lived for a period as a young child in Temple Hill, also known as Temple Hill Hospital, in Blackrock, County Dublin. She wants the Minister to add it to the institutions covered by the Mother and Baby Institutions Payment Scheme Act 2023, which would allow her to claim redress.
The Minister refused because she took the view that Temple Hill was not an institution established for pregnancy related and infant care services and the placement of children for adoption or care arrangements. Section 49(1) of the Act only allows her to add institutions of that kind.
On 16 February 2026 the High Court (Owens J.) found that the Minister had not properly applied that test. He said the key issue was the purpose for which an institution was established. The court set aside her refusal and told her to reconsider Ms Thornton's application. It ordered costs against the Minister but stayed its order pending appeal.
The Minister argued that the ruling affects how she uses her section 49 powers, with practical and financial consequences. She also pointed to the time-sensitive nature of the scheme, which runs for five years from 20 March 2024.
The High Court dealt with a similar case by John Kiernan, who had spent time in St Joseph's Baby Home in Stamullen, County Meath. The Supreme Court granted leave in that case on the same day, and the two appeals will be heard together.
The Supreme Court said eligibility for redress is clearly a matter of general public importance. It said it is in the public interest and the interests of justice that "there should be certainty as to the proper scope of the Minister's power under section 49(1)".