localnews.ie

Dan Dowling granted Supreme Court appeal over Shannon Airport trespass conviction

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will examine the common-law defence of necessity and whether it can be relied on in a case of direct action, after a protest involving a US Navy aircraft.

The Supreme Court granted Dan Dowling leave to appeal his trespass conviction from the Court of Appeal, in a determination dated 29 January 2026. The appeal will clarify the defence of necessity and whether it is available in a case of direct action.

Mr Dowling and a co-accused were charged with criminal damage and trespass over an incident in a restricted area of Shannon Airport on 25 April 2017. The damage alleged was writing in marker on an aircraft belonging to the US Navy.

Both men represented themselves at trial. Mr Dowling did not give evidence, but the co-accused said he was trying to reduce the number of people killed in the Middle East and that they acted with a common purpose.

The jury acquitted both men of criminal damage and convicted them of trespass. Mr Dowling appealed, and the only ground pursued was that the trial judge had not directed the jury on the defence of necessity.

The Court of Appeal accepted that necessity exists as a defence at common law and could in principle apply to this offence. It held that the defence did not arise in this case and was subject to limits, including that an act of direct action could not be relied on.

The Supreme Court said there is little Irish authority on necessity, and that clarifying its parameters is a matter of general public importance. The constitutional criteria for leave to appeal were therefore met.

It said the appeal should be grounded in the facts of the case, including how the defence relates to the trespass charge. The parties may also address the phrase "without lawful excuse" in the criminal damage offence, since Mr Dowling was acquitted of that charge.

The panel was Justices Dunne, O'Malley and Donnelly.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal