Paul Sullivan has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in a case brought by Mars Capital Finance Ireland DAC over a property at Taghart North, Shercock, County Cavan. O'Malley, Collins and Hyland JJ. gave the determination on 30 June 2026.
Mars Capital sought an injunction to restrain Mr Sullivan from remaining at the property after he re-entered it. It also asked to be substituted as plaintiff in place of Start Mortgages DAC. On 25 March 2026 the High Court (Nolan J.) allowed the substitution.
On 26 March 2026 the court held that an order for possession, an execution order and a valid warrant were in place and that vacant possession had been obtained. It granted the injunction, refused a stay, and ordered Mr Sullivan and his family to give up the property.
Mr Sullivan told the Supreme Court that the case raises the question of whether a court must examine unfair terms in a consumer contract on its own motion before enforcement. Mars Capital said the matter was a private dispute and an attempt to re-argue issues already decided.
The Supreme Court said he had given no reason why an appeal to the Court of Appeal would be unsatisfactory. It said he had not taken part in the possession proceedings and had not identified any unfair clause. It found no point of general importance and no need, in the interests of justice, for an appeal.