localnews.ie

Dean Byrne granted Supreme Court appeal over conspiracy to pervert course of justice

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Director of Public Prosecutions did not oppose leave and sought permission of its own on whether it can ever be lawful to persuade a witness not to give evidence.

The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by Dean Byrne against his conviction for conspiracy to pervert the course of justice. O'Malley J., Collins J. and Hyland J. granted leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal on 15 June 2026. This is a decision on whether the appeal can be heard, not on the merits.

Mr Byrne was tried before the Special Criminal Court. The indictment alleged that he conspired with Aaron Brady to persuade Daniel Cahill, a prosecution witness in the trial of DPP v Aaron Brady, not to give evidence. The prosecution relied on messages Mr Byrne sent to a relative of Mr Cahill, including photographs of Mr Cahill's witness statement.

Mr Byrne argued that persuading a witness not to give evidence is not necessarily unlawful. The trial court refused to direct an acquittal, held the indictment adequate and convicted him. It found he was not motivated solely by a wish to prevent false testimony.

The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 3 December 2025. It found ample evidence that he had conspired to put improper pressure on Mr Cahill, using the witness statement without authority. It did not decide whether the prosecution's wider position was correct.

Mr Byrne argued that the Court of Appeal's emphasis on the witness statement makes the offence one of strict liability. The Director of Public Prosecutions did not oppose leave. In a cross-application, it asked the Court to consider whether it can ever be lawful to seek to persuade a witness not to give evidence.

The Supreme Court held that the constitutional criteria were met because "it is in the public interest to clarify the parameters and ingredients of the offence alleged against the applicant". It granted leave on both the application and the cross-application.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal