William Mulrooney has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his dispute with solicitors Dolph McGrath and Nicholas Shee, practising as John Shee & Company Solicitors. The court gave its decision on 26 January 2026.
The Supreme Court said the costs issues were "a matter solely for the parties concerned".
The case began with a lease Mr Mulrooney and his father held. In August 2002 the lessor sued them, claiming the lease had been wrongfully repudiated, and the parties later settled.
Mr Mulrooney then sued the solicitors to obtain the original lease. The High Court dismissed that action as an abuse of process and awarded costs against him.
He challenged the Chief Legal Costs Adjudicator's report on those costs, saying he had been refused access to the solicitors' files. The High Court upheld the report, and the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal.
The Supreme Court said the case raised no matter of general public importance. It also found no interests of justice ground. His failure to apply to the High Court about privilege did not make the decision unjust.
The panel was Justices Dunne, Charleton and Woulfe.