The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by the Minister for Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform, Ireland and the Attorney General in a pension case taken by Freddie Jones. Woulfe J., Donnelly J. and Hyland J. granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 22 May 2026.
Mr Jones lived with his partner for 24 years before the partner's death in 2022. His partner was a civil servant with 27 years' service and a member of the Civil Service Spouses' and Children's Contributory Pension Scheme. Mr Jones was declared a "qualified cohabitant" by the Circuit Court on 24 January 2023. His application for a spouse's pension was refused in May 2023 because the scheme paid only to a spouse or civil partner.
He brought a judicial review. In January 2026 the High Court (Ferriter J.) declared that the scheme's failure to provide him with a spouse's pension was incompatible with Article 40.1 of the Constitution. It later quashed the Minister's refusal.
The Minister argued that the case raises questions about the effect of the Supreme Court's decision in O'Meara v. Minister for Social Protection. He also said it raises questions about how far the State, as an employer, may rely on the legal status people choose when setting pension benefits. Mr Jones accepted that the case raises a matter of general public importance and also asked for a direct appeal.
The Supreme Court agreed that the three matters raised by the Minister are of general public importance. It said the issues "may arise in a number of other cases". It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal, because the case is very likely to reach the Supreme Court and an appeal to the Court of Appeal would not narrow the issues.
The appeal will be listed for case management with a view to an early hearing date.