Noel Martin Snr and Drumgoan Developments Limited have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over costs orders made after Mr Martin was found in contempt of court. O'Malley J., Hogan J. and Hyland J. gave the determination on 22 May 2026.
The dispute is with Alan O'Neill and June Finnegan, who bought a house in a development built by Drumgoan and paid an extra €12,500 for the adjoining garage.
The High Court found Mr Martin had breached an order restraining communication with the plaintiffs, and his own undertakings to the court. As the sanction, it awarded all of the plaintiffs' legal costs against him on a solicitor-own client basis. Costs of the contempt motion were awarded against him and the company. The Court of Appeal upheld those orders in a single judgment.
Drumgoan and Mr Martin sought leave to appeal the costs orders from the Court of Appeal. They said their application depended on a separate application by Mr Martin about the contempt finding itself, and raised no separate issue.
The Supreme Court refused that application on 22 May 2026, for the reasons it gave in the related determination. It was not satisfied that the constitutional threshold for an appeal had been met.
The costs orders stand.