localnews.ie

Noel Martin Snr refused Supreme Court appeal over contempt of court finding

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court found he breached an order and his own undertakings in a garage dispute with Alan O'Neill and June Finnegan, and the Court of Appeal upheld that.

Noel Martin Snr has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a finding that he was in contempt of court in a dispute over a garage with Alan O'Neill and June Finnegan. O'Malley J., Hogan J. and Hyland J. gave the determination on 22 May 2026.

The High Court granted an order restraining the defendants from communicating directly with the plaintiffs. Mr Martin gave undertakings to the court, then sent a further message within hours. He accepted in evidence that he had breached the order, and the High Court held that he had breached both the order and his undertakings. As the sanction, it awarded the plaintiffs all their legal costs against him on a solicitor-own client basis. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision in a single judgment on 28 July 2025.

Mr Martin argued that the Court of Appeal was wrong to say personal service of a penally endorsed order could be waived or dispensed with before a contempt finding. He also relied on an EU directive on information in criminal proceedings.

The Supreme Court said he had not properly engaged with the reasoning of the lower courts. It said personal service is a general rule that admits exceptions. He was legally represented, admitted the breach in open court, and had evaded service.

It found no breach of constitutional justice and no matter of general public importance. It also saw no need for a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal