John Joseph Boyle has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over access to recordings of Court of Appeal hearings. Hogan, Murray and Hyland JJ. gave the determination on 19 May 2026. The Court said he had shown no need for them.
Mr Boyle sued a wide range of defendants over property and the registration of family lands. The leave application concerned only the Property Registration Authority, the Registry of Deeds and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine.
The High Court (Nolan J.) struck out his claims against those three. He appealed. Two days before that hearing, he asked the Court of Appeal for the digital audio recordings of earlier directions hearings and call-overs. On 27 June 2025, Allen J. refused.
The Court of Appeal delivered its main judgment on 4 March 2026. It upheld the strike-out against the Authority and the Registry. It narrowed the order against the Department, leaving only his claim that it was wrongly withholding EU funds.
The Supreme Court said Mr Boyle could point to no reason why the recordings were necessary for his appeal. It described his application as "entirely abstract".
It said the rules make access a matter for the court's discretion. It found no point of general public importance and no need, in the interests of justice, for an appeal. It also saw no EU law question requiring a reference.