localnews.ie

Paul Murphy gets Supreme Court appeal over Ministers of State at Government meetings

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Dublin South-West TD argues the practice of letting Ministers of State regularly attend Government meetings breaches the constitutional limit of 15 members.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Dublin South-West TD Paul Murphy over the regular attendance of Ministers of State at Government meetings. Hogan, Hyland and O'Moore JJ. granted leave to appeal from the High Court on 15 May 2026.

Mr Murphy brought a plenary action arguing that the practice breaches Article 28.1 of the Constitution, which limits the number of members of the Government. He also relied on Article 28.4 and on Articles 5, 6 and 13. His challenge concerned three Ministers of State appointed on the Taoiseach's nomination to the current Government.

A divisional panel of the High Court (Barniville P., Phelan and Bradley JJ.) dismissed his action in its entirety on 19 December 2025. It found no express or implied constitutional prohibition on the practice. It held that decisions are taken by the 15 members of the Government, so the Ministers of State do not undermine them.

On 6 March 2026 the High Court awarded Mr Murphy 50% of his costs. The same panel dismissed a similar judicial review by Deputy Patrick Daly on the same day, and his application for leave is being dealt with in a separate determination.

Mr Murphy told the Supreme Court that the case goes to the core of the constitutionality of Government meetings and is the first time an Irish court has decided the issue. The respondents, including the Taoiseach and the Attorney General, opposed leave. They said the appeal involves a straightforward application of the Constitution.

The Supreme Court said the case raised "a novel issue of constitutional interpretation which is of exceptional importance". It said clarity is needed on whether the practice complies with the Constitution.

It also granted the respondents leave to cross-appeal the High Court's costs judgment. It noted Mr Murphy's contention that the appeal is urgent and said a case management hearing will be organised in early course.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal