localnews.ie

Peter Nowak refused Supreme Court appeal in long-running exam script data dispute

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

His complaint to the Data Protection Commission over examination scripts held by Chartered Accountants Ireland dates from 1 July 2010 and has been before the courts several times.

The Supreme Court refused Peter Nowak leave to appeal in his case against the Data Protection Commission on 20 January 2026. The dispute began with a complaint he made on 1 July 2010 about access to his examination scripts.

Mr Nowak had been studying a course run by Chartered Accountants Ireland and made a data access request to the institute. The Commission found that the scripts did not contain his personal data and declined to investigate parts of his complaint.

The Supreme Court overturned earlier decisions in 2016 and sent the matter back to the Commission. A later decision on 21 April 2022 found no merit in his remaining points, and the Circuit Court, High Court and Court of Appeal all upheld it.

Mr Nowak asked the Supreme Court to consider questions about the Commission's powers and how it investigates complaints. He also argued that the Court of Appeal had wrongly treated his later email as a reformulated complaint.

The court found no matter of general public importance and nothing in the interests of justice. It called the application "quite clearly an attempt to relitigate issues of fact already decided".

The panel was Justices Dunne, Charleton and Donnelly.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal