localnews.ie

Denis Jude Haughton refused Supreme Court appeal over WRC and Department of Enterprise complaint

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court had refused him leave on 17 November 2025 to bring judicial review proceedings, an ex parte application, over the response to an earlier Supreme Court decision.

The Supreme Court refused Denis Jude Haughton leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 2 April 2026, in a case against the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment. Direct appeals from the High Court require exceptional circumstances, and the court found the threshold was not met.

Mr Haughton's earlier dispute began with a complaint to the Workplace Relations Commission in March 2022 about the terms of his employment. The Labour Court dismissed his appeal, and the courts refused him leave for judicial review, including this court in a 2024 determination.

He returned to the High Court, claiming that decision had not been acted on and that the Minister and the Commission had stopped communicating with him. He sought an order for the Minister to reply and a certificate that "work has been done", so that an advance of around €100,000 could be released.

The High Court refused leave, finding he was in substance seeking the same relief as before. The Supreme Court agreed, saying the application would amount to a collateral attack on a matter already decided.

It found his arguments concern the particular facts of his case and would have no wider application. It also noted that the Minister and the Commission were not joined to the proceedings.

The panel was Justices O'Malley, Hogan and Murray.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal