localnews.ie

Brian Donohoe refused Supreme Court mortgage appeal

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said repeated EU case law makes clear that a borrower using a loan for rental business purposes is not a consumer.

The Supreme Court refused Brian Donohoe leave to appeal a mortgage possession ruling on 23 March 2026.

Permanent TSB approved him a €543,450 loan in April 2007. It was secured on two properties in Galway and Dublin.

He made no payments after July 2010. Permanent TSB later sold the loan.

Mars Capital Finance Ireland became the owner of the charges.

The High Court sent the possession case to a full hearing. The Court of Appeal reversed that on 10 November 2025.

Mr Donohoe argued he was a consumer under EU unfair terms rules. He said many mortgage customers could be affected.

The Court of Appeal found a business purpose. His rental income was the only source disclosed for repaying the loan.

The Supreme Court said EU case law on the point was beyond argument. It found no matter of general public importance.

It saw no need to refer the issue to the European Court of Justice.

The panel was Justices O'Malley, Woulfe and Hogan.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal