The Supreme Court granted Seán Harte, Patrick McCarthy, John O'Meara and Geraldine Balfe leave to appeal against the Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland on 20 March 2026.
The case concerns an offer letter of 10 November 2009. The bank proposed lending the plaintiffs €12.2 million and €2.8 million for property development.
Clause 5 allowed the bank to change the method of calculating interest, and the interest rate, at its absolute discretion. It required one month's prior notice.
The plaintiffs say the bank wrongly changed the reference rate in October 2011, from Euribor to the Bank's Cost of Funds. They say they would have saved about €700,000 on the now-discharged borrowing.
The High Court and the Court of Appeal both ruled against them. The Court of Appeal held that the words "or otherwise" did not limit the bank's discretion to changes in market conventions.
The plaintiffs argued that the clause touches many more contracts than their own, with eight thousand customers said to be affected. They also said the bank used the change to serve its own interests. The bank said the matter is between the parties, and that any wider claims are statute barred.
The Supreme Court said the standard clause affected many more customers than the plaintiffs. It said it is important to decide what limits apply to such a discretion clause.
The court listed two grounds of appeal, namely the proper construction of the clause and whether any limits apply to the bank's discretion. Both may be refined at case management.
The panel was Justices Charleton, O'Malley and Hogan.