localnews.ie

Paul King granted Supreme Court appeal against surrender to UK over historical sexual offence claims

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr King argues he could face a heavier sentence in the UK now than he would have around 1990, and the court said the issue is likely to recur.

The Supreme Court granted Paul King leave to appeal directly from the High Court against an order for his surrender to the UK, in a determination dated 20 March 2026.

The UK warrant, issued on 25 January 2025, seeks his surrender to be prosecuted for alleged sexual offences said to have been committed between 1976 and 1988. On 19 January 2026 the High Court ordered his surrender under the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003.

Mr King objected that, if convicted, he would face a heavier sentence than he would have received if tried around 1990. He relied on an expert opinion and argued that this engaged his rights under the European Convention on Human Rights and the EU Charter.

The High Court accepted the premise of the expert opinion but held that a more severe sentencing regime in the UK was not in itself a breach of his rights. It noted that sentencing law in Ireland had also become more severe. The judge refused a certificate allowing an appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The Minister for Justice opposed leave. The Minister said the argument rested on speculation about a future sentencing exercise and that any issue could be raised in the UK.

The Supreme Court said the issue is whether surrender can be refused where there are substantial grounds to believe the person would face a materially heavier sentence than at the time of the alleged offending. It added that this includes whether Irish sentencing law becoming more severe is relevant.

It held that the issue goes beyond the facts of this case and is capable of recurring. It also found exceptional circumstances warranted a direct appeal.

The panel was Justices O'Malley, Hogan and Murray.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal