The Supreme Court granted the Minister for Justice leave to appeal a High Court refusal to surrender Paul Lomas to the UK on 16 March 2026.
The UK sought his surrender on a warrant dated 6 August 2024. He would serve a custodial sentence.
The sentence covered six offences. Five were dealt with by a composite sentence in the Crown Court in Northern Ireland on 14 June 2010.
Three of those offences were breaches of an Interim Risk of Sexual Harm Order. The sixth was an accusation matter.
Mr Lomas objected to surrender on several grounds. He said the offences did not match offences in Irish law. He also relied on his right to private and family life.
The High Court refused surrender on one ground only. That ground was Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The judge found a long time had passed and Mr Lomas had built a settled family life here. He had also served the custodial part of the sentence.
Leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal had been refused. The Minister therefore applied directly to the Supreme Court.
The Minister argues that the High Court lowered the high threshold for refusing surrender on those grounds.
The Supreme Court said the question arises often and clarity is important. It found exceptional circumstances justified a direct appeal.
It also allowed Mr Lomas to cross-appeal on whether the offences correspond to offences in Irish law. That point concerns the Northern Irish order regime and its Irish comparator.
The panel was Justices O'Malley, Hogan and Murray.