The Supreme Court refused Oonagh Cahill, a minor, leave to appeal directly from the High Court in her case against the Health Service Executive on 9 March 2026.
Oonagh sued through her father, Ian Cahill, in a medical negligence action over St Luke's General Hospital, Kilkenny.
She claims damages for brain injury allegedly caused by delay in diagnosing hydrocephalus. The Health Service Executive has a full defence on liability and causation.
She asked the High Court to decide a question about damages as a preliminary issue. It concerned whether taxes should count when setting the discount rate for future loss.
The High Court refused on 13 November 2025 and ordered a single trial of all issues.
The Supreme Court said the High Court had not decided the discount rate question itself. It had only decided how the case should be managed.
It found that appeal raised no matter of general public importance. It also found that the interests of justice were not met merely because the case is serious.
The panel was Justices O'Malley, Murray and Collins.