The Supreme Court has granted Jason Bonney leave to appeal his conviction, in a determination dated 6 March 2026. The appeal concerns what counts as alibi evidence under the Criminal Justice Act 1984.
The court said: "Alibi evidence is of potential importance to many criminal trials."
The Special Criminal Court convicted Bonney on 17 April 2023 of participating in a criminal organisation by providing access to his black BMW on 5 February 2016. That was the day a six-man armed team attacked the Regency Hotel, killing David Byrne. He was sentenced to eight and a half years.
Bonney said his late father, William Bonney, had taken the BMW that morning. Two defence witnesses supported him, and one said he saw William Bonney driving the car.
The Special Criminal Court treated that evidence as alibi-type evidence. No alibi notice had been served, so it allowed the prosecution to call a rebuttal witness. The Court of Appeal upheld the conviction on 10 November 2025.
Bonney argues that the courts widened the meaning of alibi to cover evidence about a third party. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave and said the Court of Appeal made no error.
The Supreme Court said it must decide whether alibi covers evidence other than that placing the accused elsewhere. It will also consider rebuttal evidence and the effect of not raising a point at trial.
The issues are the meaning of section 20, rebuttal evidence, failure to raise a point, and whether the verdict was safe. The panel was Justices Charleton, Murray and Collins.