localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear Diesel SPA appeal over DIESEL trademark registration in Ireland

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The long-running dispute with Irish company Montex Holdings began with trademark applications in the 1990s under the Trade Marks Act 1963, which has since been repealed.

The Supreme Court granted Diesel SPA leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision on 26 February 2026. The appeal concerns the company's bid to register the DIESEL trademark in Ireland against Montex Holdings Limited and the Controller of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks.

Montex applied to register the mark in 1992, and Diesel SPA opposed. The Controller refused Montex's application in 1998. Diesel SPA applied in 1994, and the Controller ultimately refused that application too.

Diesel SPA appealed to the High Court, which found that Montex had improperly and dishonestly copied the mark. The court held that Diesel SPA was entitled to register it.

The Court of Appeal reversed that decision and confirmed the Controller's refusal. It held that Montex's ownership of the mark had already been decided in earlier proceedings and could not be reopened. It also held that the confusion test in the 1963 Act looks at the fact of confusion, not its cause.

Diesel SPA argued that the issues raised general public importance, including res judicata and whether Montex can rely on confusion it created. The Controller did not oppose leave, while Montex opposed it.

The Supreme Court accepted that the 1963 Act has been replaced but said the issues go beyond that Act. It identified the use of res judicata or issue estoppel in trademark cases, and the interaction of the statute with equitable principles.

It also found an appeal was in the interests of justice, given the length of the litigation. It granted the Controller leave to cross-appeal and set a timetable for written submissions.

The panel was Justices Charleton, Woulfe and Collins.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal