The Supreme Court refused Wayne Peter Landman and Belinda Page leave to appeal on 26 February 2026, ending their challenge over South Africa's designation as a safe country of origin.
It also refused them an extension of time to appeal the High Court judgment directly.
The couple's claim for international protection was rejected. The International Protection Appeals Tribunal accepted that they had been victims of crime on at least five occasions. It found they did not have a well-founded fear of persecution and that state protection was available.
The High Court dismissed their judicial review of that decision and of the Minister's decision to maintain the designation. The Court of Appeal later dismissed their appeal, finding they lacked standing to challenge the designation because it played no role in the tribunal's decision.
Mr Landman and Ms Page argued that a recent European Court of Justice ruling required guidance from the Supreme Court. They also said they faced possible return to South Africa.
The Supreme Court said they had chosen to appeal to the Court of Appeal, so they could not now go back and appeal the High Court judgment directly. It found no matter of general public importance and no need for a European court reference.
Leave to appeal was refused. The panel was Justices Charleton, Woulfe and Collins.