localnews.ie

Paul Clements Ryanair PRSI case: Minister for Social Protection refused Supreme Court appeal

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The State side had asked to appeal directly from the High Court a ruling that set aside a finding that pilot Paul Clements was employed by Ryanair.

The Supreme Court refused the Minister for Social Protection, an Appeals Officer and the Chief Appeals Officer leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 18 February 2026. The case concerns whether pilot Paul Clements was employed by Ryanair between 15 February 2010 and 30 April 2014 for PRSI purposes.

An Appeals Officer decided on 12 July 2021 that Mr Clements had been in insurable employment with Ryanair, reversing an earlier 2016 finding. The Chief Appeals Officer upheld that decision, and Ryanair appealed to the High Court.

On 26 November 2024 the High Court set aside the 2021 decision, finding it was based on an erroneous view of the law and that no reasonable decision-maker could have inferred an employment relationship.

The applicants said the case raised systemic questions about how employment status is decided and that 45 similar cases were on hold. Ryanair opposed leave and said the appeal turned on facts.

The Supreme Court held that the case was better suited to the Court of Appeal. It noted that the proposed appeal raised sixteen grounds, which makes a direct appeal inappropriate, and found no exceptional or urgent circumstances.

The panel was Justices Dunne, Charleton and Woulfe.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal