Piotr Skoczylas, John Paul McGann, Tibor Neugebauer and Scotchstone Capital Fund Ltd have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a case involving Permanent TSB Group Holdings PLC. O'Malley, Hogan and O'Moore JJ. gave the determination on 31 August 2026.
The case relates to a proposed acquisition of the bank by the Austrian banking group BAWAG PSK. The bank asked the High Court to direct a scheme meeting of shareholders, proposed for 30 July 2026.
The applicants asked the High Court to declare that the Minister for Finance, who held 57.5% of the shares, should be in a separate class. Sanfey J. held that class composition is usually examined at the later sanction stage. The applicants appealed, but the Court of Appeal struck out their appeals on 8 July 2026 after only Mr McGann appeared and made no submissions.
Mr Skoczylas had asked for a remote hearing for family reasons, and the request was refused. The applicants argued that an appeal cannot be struck out without considering its merits, and that refusing a remote link was unfair.
The Supreme Court said the onus is on an appellant to attend court and move the matter. It said there is no entitlement to a remote hearing. It noted that the applicants can still argue class composition in the High Court at the sanction stage. It found no point of general public importance and no need, in the interests of justice, for a further appeal.