The Supreme Court has granted limited leave to appeal to Rural Residents Wind Aware and Environmental Group, John Nolan and Catriona Nolan. O'Malley, Woulfe and Donnelly JJ. gave the determination on 4 August 2026. The appeal will be listed for case management with a related case.
The applicants challenged An Coimisiún Pleanála's permission for a seven-turbine wind farm. White Hill Wind Limited is the notice party. They lost in the High Court (Humphreys J.), which gave six written judgments across two sets of proceedings.
Two turbines were originally to sit on lands the developer did not own. One landowner was the second-named applicant. The applicants said the commission should have refused to deal with the application. The High Court held that any invalidity could be cured if a later alteration survived challenge.
That alteration was made under section 146B of the Planning and Development Act 2000. The Supreme Court granted leave on this issue only. It said the question is whether missing landowner consent can be cured by using the section. The parties should address the need for landowner consent.
The Court refused leave on the other issues. These concerned how the commission assessed noise and shadow flicker and its duties to people more affected. It said the High Court applied well-established principles.
The case will be heard with the related appeal in the same dispute. Each party will lodge one set of submissions. The notice party sought a priority hearing. The Court said an early hearing should be possible without a formal priority designation, if time limits are met.