localnews.ie

Jerry Beades refused Supreme Court appeal over Court of Appeal recusal decision

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The case involves Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC, James Anderson and properties at Richmond Avenue, Fairview, and Little Mary Street, Dublin 1.

Jerry Beades has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a Court of Appeal decision not to recuse its President, in a case against James Anderson and Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC. O'Malley, Hogan and Hyland JJ. gave the determination on 30 July 2026.

On 27 June 2025, the High Court (Dignam J.) struck out Mr Beades's claims in three sets of proceedings, including those against Pepper and the receiver. It found they were an abuse of process, frivolous and vexatious and bound to fail. It also barred him from issuing further proceedings about 31 Richmond Avenue, Fairview, Dublin 3 and 21 Little Mary Street, Dublin 1, against Pepper, Deloitte and its partners or employees without leave.

Mr Beades appealed. His appeal was listed in the Court of Appeal for 23 March 2026.

On 13 March 2026 he asked the President, Costello P., to recuse herself for objective bias, based on two judgments she gave as a High Court judge in his litigation. She refused in an ex tempore decision.

He then applied to the Supreme Court. This was one of four identically worded applications.

The Supreme Court said none of his issues arose from the recusal decision. It said such decisions are reviewed only in the most exceptional circumstances. The Court of Appeal had not yet decided the substantive appeal, and the Supreme Court expressed no view on it.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal