localnews.ie

Alan Harte granted Supreme Court appeal over Special Criminal Court majority verdicts

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr Harte was sentenced to 30 years by the Special Criminal Court and challenges the law allowing majority verdicts without disclosing whether the verdict was unanimous.

The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by Alan Harte over the law that allows the Special Criminal Court to deliver majority verdicts. Woulfe J., Hogan J. and Donnelly J. granted leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal on 16 July 2026. The Court also extended the time for his application.

Mr Harte was charged in November 2019 with false imprisonment and causing serious harm. The Director of Public Prosecutions certified that the case should go before the Special Criminal Court. He was tried with three other accused, found guilty on 8 November 2021 and sentenced to 30 years in prison in December 2021. The sentence was backdated to 26 November 2019.

He brought a judicial review challenging section 40 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1939. He argued that it allows a two-thirds majority verdict, and that the accused is not told whether the verdict is unanimous or by majority. He said this breaches Articles 34.1, 38 and 40.1 of the Constitution.

The High Court (Bolger J.) rejected the challenge. The Court of Appeal (Hyland J.) dismissed his appeal. It held that Article 38 does not require a trial before the Special Criminal Court to be equivalent to a jury trial, and that he had no comparator for his equality argument.

Mr Harte said a diary error by his solicitor caused the late application, and the respondents did not oppose an extension. They opposed leave, saying his points rest on a comparison with jury trials.

The Supreme Court said the appeal raises matters of general public importance. They concern the use of a qualified majority verdict in the Special Criminal Court and the ban on disclosing whether the decision was unanimous.

Leave is limited to the challenge to the constitutionality of section 40. The Court drew the parties' attention to its earlier decision in The State (Littlejohn) v. Governor of Mountjoy Prison.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal