The Supreme Court on 7 July 2025 granted Táilte Éireann, formerly the Commissioner of Valuation, leave to appeal a High Court judgment in its case against Redwood Extended Care Facility. Dunne J, Woulfe J and Murray J made the determination.
Redwood runs a designated centre for adults with disabilities in a two-storey detached property on the outskirts of Stamullen, Co. Meath. The Valuation Tribunal gave the property a nil valuation under a rates exemption in Schedule 4 of the Valuation Act 2001.
Táilte Éireann appealed to the High Court on a point of law. It has also appealed to the Court of Appeal. Bradley J. gave one judgment covering this case and the related NUA Healthcare Services case, and he upheld the tribunal's decision.
The Supreme Court said the grounds met the constitutional threshold of exceptional circumstances for an appeal directly from the High Court. It noted that the appeal is agreed to raise an issue of law that would be likely to reach the Supreme Court in any event.
It also found a question of general public importance. That question is whether the exemption applies where the Exchequer has a service level agreement with a provider and pays only for service users present from time to time. The court said it had not previously considered the matter.
Táilte Éireann argued that the ruling could affect many properties and could increase the burden on other ratepayers. Redwood opposed leave.
The Supreme Court has also granted leave in the NUA Healthcare case. Both appeals will be heard together, and a case management hearing will be arranged, with the date to be given to the parties.