The Supreme Court on 7 July 2025 granted Táilte Éireann, formerly the Commissioner of Valuation, leave to appeal a High Court ruling in its case against NUA Healthcare Services Limited.
NUA Healthcare operates a designated centre for children with disabilities in a five-bedroom dormer bungalow in Kiltinan, Co. Tipperary. The Valuation Tribunal gave the property a nil valuation, finding it fell within a rates exemption in the Valuation Act 2001.
Táilte Éireann appealed that decision to the High Court on a point of law. Bradley J. upheld the tribunal, holding that the exemption applied because the Exchequer paid the money the provider used to meet its costs.
Táilte Éireann told the Supreme Court the case raises a point of public importance on how the exemption should be read. It argued that the ruling could affect many properties and could shift the burden onto other ratepayers.
Táilte Éireann has also appealed to the Court of Appeal. It asked the Supreme Court to set aside the High Court order and to send the matter back to the Valuation Tribunal.
NUA Healthcare opposed leave. It argued that the High Court was right and that few care centres are rated. It said the Court of Appeal could deal with any issue of interpretation.
The Supreme Court found the grounds met the constitutional threshold of exceptional circumstances for an appeal directly from the High Court. It will hear this appeal together with the related Redwood Extended Care Facility case, and will hold a case management hearing, with the date to be notified to the parties.