localnews.ie

Peter and Maureen O'Donnell refused Supreme Court appeal over Isaac Wunder orders

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple sought to appeal a High Court refusal of permission to bring fresh proceedings against the Government of Ireland and others, despite orders restricting new cases.

The Supreme Court refused Peter and Maureen O'Donnell leave to appeal a High Court decision on 1 July 2025. The panel was Charleton J, Murray J and Collins J.

The couple wanted to appeal directly from the High Court. Three Isaac Wunder orders made by Cregan J on 7 May 2024 barred them from issuing proceedings against the State and others without prior leave.

On 30 January 2025, Nolan J refused their application for permission to bring new proceedings against the Government of Ireland and others. He found the claims were similar to those they were already prohibited from pursuing. The couple argued they were immune from court summons under the equality guarantee in Article 40.1 of the Constitution.

The Supreme Court said the grounds did not meet the constitutional threshold of exceptional circumstances needed for an appeal straight from the High Court. It found no matter of general public importance and no basis in the interests of justice to grant leave.

The court said Nolan J had considered the application carefully and explained his reasons clearly. It added that the law was settled and no new issues arose.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal