Vesel Jahiri has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his conviction for murder. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 30 May 2025, so his conviction stands.
Mr Jahiri was convicted on 12 April 2017 of the murder of Anna Finnegan, his former partner and the mother of his two children. The offence took place at her home on 21 September 2012. He was also convicted of assaulting her brother, Karl Finnegan.
The court heard that a safety plan had been put in place for Ms Finnegan, including her brother staying with her and the locks being changed. Mr Jahiri accepted that he broke the door in, struggled with Mr Finnegan and stabbed him more than once. The accounts of what happened to Ms Finnegan conflicted.
Mr Jahiri appealed to the Court of Appeal, which rejected his complaints in a judgment of 27 February 2024. It held that the issues he raised were for the jury to decide, and that there was no evidential basis for his allegations.
O'Malley J., Hogan J. and Woulfe J. said his application rested on assertions about the evidence at trial. They said these were questions of fact for the jury, not an appeal court.
The court found no legal issue of general public importance, and no need for an appeal in the interests of justice. Leave was refused.