The Supreme Court has granted Protect East Meath Limited leave to appeal directly from the High Court in its case against Meath County Council. The determination was delivered on 23 May 2025.
Protect East Meath is a nonprofit organisation that aims to secure the strongest possible environmental protection for future development in East Meath. It sought an order of mandamus to make the council start the process of making a new Local Area Plan (LAP) for the area.
The previous LAP was adopted in July 2014 and expired in October 2020. The council is required to publish a notice of its proposal to make a new LAP at least every six years, and it did not start the process in time.
In August 2023, the group wrote to the council. In September 2023, the council replied that other plans had greater priority and that its resources were limited. The group began judicial review proceedings in June 2024. In October 2024, the council offered to consent to a declaration that it was in breach of its obligations. The group did not accept this and the case went to trial.
On 14 March 2025, Nolan J. in the High Court refused mandamus. He found that the council's circumstances, taken together, amounted to exceptional circumstances. He said it would be unjust to order a plan for one part of County Meath only.
Charleton J., O'Malley J. and Woulfe J. found that the case raises a matter of general public importance. The question is when a court may decline mandamus against a planning authority that has not met a mandatory duty. The court said earlier reasoning in Brady v Cavan County Council may need to be reassessed.
They held that exceptional circumstances justify a direct appeal, because it may bring greater legal certainty. The grounds may be refined at case management.