The Supreme Court has granted Shay Sweeney and The Limerick Private Ltd leave to appeal an order requiring the company to provide security for costs. The determination was delivered on 16 May 2025.
The applicants say the order will end their proceedings unless they provide security of €1,790,500 within six weeks. Their case claims abuse of dominant position by the Voluntary Health Insurance Board.
They wished to set up a private hospital in Limerick and negotiated with the VHI to have it approved for insurance purposes. The VHI did not approve cover. The applicants began proceedings on 26 May 2015.
On 28 June 2023, the VHI applied for security for costs against the company. The High Court (Barrett J.) granted the order on 11 October 2023. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on 31 January 2025.
The applicants argued that the VHI waited too long to seek security. The Court of Appeal accepted the delay was long but found no evidence of prejudice to the applicants. It said they had decided to proceed despite the possibility of such an order.
The applicants say High Court decisions differ on how much prejudice a party must show when delay is argued against security. The VHI opposes leave. It says the appeal is interlocutory and the applicants would lose on either approach.
O'Malley J., Hogan J. and Donnelly J. said the case raises a matter of significant practical importance in the commercial field. The question is how prejudice is to be assessed when there is lengthy delay before a motion for security for costs. The applicants may appeal on all the grounds in their notice of appeal.