The Supreme Court has granted Barry Sheehan leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a dispute with Charles Crowley and Raymond Crowley over a house in Cork. The determination was delivered on 12 May 2025.
The case could decide whether tenants in similar leases keep the right to buy out the fee simple in their homes. The court said Mr Sheehan's reading of the law could mean sub-lessees would lose that right for domestic dwellings built under their sub-lease.
The Crowleys hold a 150-year sublease, dated 12 April 1940, of 1b Anneville, Coolgarten Park, Magazine Road, Cork. Mr Sheehan acquired the interest of their former lessor in February 2022 and became head landlord. The Crowleys then applied to the Cork County Registrar to buy the fee simple under the Landlord and Tenant (Ground Rents) (No. 2) Act 1978.
Mr Sheehan argued that the head lease had no covenant to build, so it was a non-qualifying lease under section 16(2)(f) of the Act, and that the application was out of time. The County Registrar disagreed and ordered him to assign his interest to the Crowleys.
The Circuit Court and then the High Court (Nolan J.) upheld that decision. Nolan J. found the aim of the section was focused on leases connected to supermarket developments. He said Mr Sheehan's reading would be an absurdity.
Mr Sheehan then sought to appeal straight to the Supreme Court. Dunne J., Murray J. and Collins J. said the interpretation of the section raises a matter of general public importance.
Because so many people could be affected, the court said it could raise a question of constitutional interpretation. It will send the Attorney General a copy of the determination and invite him to take part.
The case will be listed for case management soon. Leave to appeal is granted.