Jamie Lordan has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in his challenge to the stopping of his disability allowance while he was in prison. Charleton, Collins and Donnelly JJ delivered the determination on 22 January 2025.
The court heard that Mr Lordan received disability allowance because of a permanent disability. The Minister for Social Protection stopped payments during periods when he was lawfully detained. A review was refused on 5 May 2022, on the basis that he no longer met the qualifying criteria in section 210 of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005.
He sought judicial review, claiming that the provisions were unconstitutional. On 9 July 2024 the High Court (Bolger J.) refused his claims. It held that the allowance stopped because imprisonment was a second reason, besides disability, why he could not work, and was not an extra punishment.
Mr Lordan argued that the law had the same effect as a pension rule the Supreme Court struck down in an earlier case. He also relied on equality and human rights arguments.
The Supreme Court said the High Court had thoroughly considered those issues, so no exceptional circumstances justified skipping the Court of Appeal. It said the European Convention on Human Rights issue should also be considered by the Court of Appeal.