Brian McHugh, who is charged with the murder of Lisa Thompson in Ballymun, Dublin 11, has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. Dunne J., Hogan J. and Collins J. made the determination on 21 January 2025.
The charge relates to her home on 9 May 2022. The prosecution case is circumstantial and includes CCTV footage.
Mr McHugh wanted to challenge a Court of Appeal ruling that allowed the jury to hear garda recognition evidence from CCTV footage. At a preliminary hearing on 19 March 2024, the Central Criminal Court had excluded that evidence from the two gardaí.
The trial judge found that both gardaí had been involved in the investigation and knew Mr McHugh to be a person of interest. The prosecution appealed, and on 4 July 2024 the Court of Appeal reversed the ruling so the evidence could go before the jury.
Mr McHugh argued that the case raised questions about when a judge may exclude garda identification evidence at a preliminary hearing. He also sought guidance on the Court of Appeal's role under section 7 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2021. The prosecution opposed leave.
The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had dealt with his arguments fully and in line with well-established case law. It accepted that this may have been the first section 7 appeal but said novelty alone did not justify a further appeal. The constitutional threshold was not met.