localnews.ie

Robert Alan Roberts refused Supreme Court appeal in £35,000 dispute with brother over Wexford property

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had sent the case back to the High Court for a full hearing, and the Supreme Court urged the brothers to consider mediation.

Robert Alan Roberts has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a dispute with his brother, David Ian Roberts. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 4 March 2025.

The brothers fell out over the sale of their late father's Lancashire property, which Robert says David sold for about £70,000 sterling and kept the proceeds. Robert won a judgment in England and Wales for £35,000 sterling plus interest. He then sought a well charging order over a property in Co. Wexford owned by David's wife, Janice.

The High Court made the order, but the Court of Appeal allowed David's appeal. It found that key evidence from Janice, who said she bought the property without funds from her husband, had not been fully considered. It sent the case back to the High Court for a full hearing.

Hogan J., Murray J. and Collins J. extended time for Robert's late application. They said the Court of Appeal had applied settled principles, which raised no point of general importance, and a further appeal was not necessary in the interests of justice.

The court called it a pity that a small sum had led to such costly litigation and urged the parties to consider mediation.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal