localnews.ie

Gordon Smith granted Supreme Court appeal over access to recordings of criminal trial evidence

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Balbriggan man wants transcripts of witness evidence from a criminal trial for use in KBC Bank's possession case against him; the High Court said it had no jurisdiction.

The Supreme Court has granted Gordon Smith leave to appeal a High Court decision about access to recordings of evidence given in a criminal trial. The determination was delivered on 24 February 2025.

Mr Smith and his wife are defendants, with a third person, in possession proceedings brought by KBC Bank Ireland Plc over a former family home in Balbriggan. A possession order was made by the County Registrar in 2016. The bank was unable to execute it, and in 2018 the High Court directed the defendants to vacate the premises.

In February, March and April 2023, a separate prosecution took place in the Dublin Circuit Court over violent disorder at an attempted repossession in Falsk, Co Roscommon. Three defendants were convicted and a fourth acquitted. Witnesses included a bank officer and two people connected with security services, who had also sworn affidavits in Mr Smith's possession case.

In January 2024, Mr Smith applied to the Circuit Court for the digital audio recording or transcripts of their evidence. On 29 February 2024, the President of the Circuit Court directed that certain portions of the transcript be provided to him, with restrictions on spreading them.

Mr Smith appealed to the High Court. On 14 June 2024, Owens J. found that the High Court had no jurisdiction, because its appeal powers cover civil matters and not orders made in criminal proceedings. He dismissed the appeal.

O'Malley J., Murray J. and Collins J. found that the constitutional criteria for an appeal had been met. They said the appeal raises points of general public importance. These include whether the Circuit Court order was made in a criminal or a civil matter, what test applies to such applications, who should be notified, and what limits may be placed on use of the material.

The court noted that Mr Smith represents himself and said a scheme of legal representation is available to him. This ruling decides only that the appeal may go ahead.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal