localnews.ie

Noel Noonan granted Supreme Court appeal over garda search of seized car in drugs case

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had quashed his conviction and ordered a retrial on other grounds, but upheld the search of the car under the doctrine of self-protection.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Noel Noonan over the search of a car in which gardaí found drugs. It granted him leave on 21 January 2025. Charleton, Collins and Donnelly JJ made the determination.

The court said the question of the gardaí's common law power to search a vehicle that has already been lawfully seized is a matter of general public importance.

On 13 February 2017, Garda Dave Farragher stopped Mr Noonan on the N7 motorway. The car was not taxed, he was not insured, and he could not produce a driving licence. The car was seized and taken to a garda compound in Naas. A search found 6.6 kg of amphetamine with a market value of approximately €100,000, and alprazolam worth €37,000.

In February 2023, a jury unanimously convicted Mr Noonan on all counts. They included possession of drugs worth more than €13,000 for sale or supply. He was sentenced to nine years, with the final six months suspended.

The Court of Appeal quashed the conviction on 15 October 2024 and ordered a retrial, because hearsay evidence had been wrongly admitted. It described the running of the trial as "unconventional". It also held that the search was permitted under the doctrine of self-protection.

Mr Noonan sought leave to appeal on whether the search was lawful. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed, saying he was in effect appealing an order in his favour.

The Supreme Court asked what authority gardaí have at common law, or by statute, to search a vehicle lawfully taken into custody once a reasonable suspicion arises that it contains unlawful items.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal