Yeoksee Ooi has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a dispute over a property at Delgany, County Wicklow. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 17 February 2025.
Ms Ooi, a notice party in the case, wanted to appeal directly from the High Court, which had dismissed an appeal against a Circuit Court order giving Promontoria Scariff DAC possession of the house. The order carried an eighteen-month stay on execution. The defendant in the case is Brian McDonagh.
The court heard that Ms Ooi has lived at the property since 2006 and has three children with Mr McDonagh. She has separate High Court proceedings challenging part of the Family Home Protection Act 1976.
The Supreme Court said the constitutional question arises in those separate proceedings, not in the possession case, so it was not a matter of general public importance. It said she had already had a full Circuit Court hearing and a High Court appeal. Her application was also filed late, and she gave no reasonable explanation for the delay.
The court added that the separate proceedings should go to trial as speedily as possible.